Page 1 of 4

Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 11:46am
by Sarah
Welcome to 2020!

What a time to be alive! :thumbdown:

https://www.businessinsider.com/brexit- ... -eu-2020-1

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 12:10pm
by gle1975
If we had not joined the EU in the 70s and had a different arrangement like Norway, Switzerland etc, the UK may have performed better. So perhaps joining the EEC lost load of money!

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 12:42pm
by parchedpeas
gle1975 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 12:10pm
If we had not joined the EU in the 70s and had a different arrangement like Norway, Switzerland etc, the UK may have performed better. So perhaps joining the EEC lost load of money!
Utter nonsense. It's the introduction of the single market that has supercharged our economy and kept manufacturing alive in the UK. Which is why Norway and the Swiss are (de facto) inside it.

There isn't a single economic prediction that says leaving the Single Market will be better for us. Not one. Anywhere. From anyone. And there won't be either, because removing tariffs and friction makes sense. We're the only country in the world to ever do the opposite.

But LOOK OVER THERE BIG BEN! And that's enough to distract the masses in this low-productivity, low skills country.

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 12:59pm
by Boro Boy
The price of freedom never comes cheap!

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
by expressman33
There is a cost either way and the fact remains that Britain was paying an extremely high amount compared to other countries to stay in the EU. Its done now so people need to accept the result and get over it as they should've when it was voted for. We've lost more money with the uncertainty and still didn't get as bad as predicted.

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 1:51pm
by parchedpeas
expressman33 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
There is a cost either way and the fact remains that Britain was paying an extremely high amount compared to other countries to stay in the EU. Its done now so people need to accept the result and get over it as they should've when it was voted for. We've lost more money with the uncertainty and still didn't get as bad as predicted.
It's far from done because "IT" still hasn't been defined.

And thanks for telling me to 'get over it'. I make three people unemployed later this month - directly Brexit related.

I'll pass on your regards.
Boro Boy wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 12:59pm
The price of freedom never comes cheap!
As if you've ever paid a price for "freedom".

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 2:19pm
by Boro Boy
parchedpeas wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:51pm
expressman33 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
There is a cost either way and the fact remains that Britain was paying an extremely high amount compared to other countries to stay in the EU. Its done now so people need to accept the result and get over it as they should've when it was voted for. We've lost more money with the uncertainty and still didn't get as bad as predicted.
It's far from done because "IT" still hasn't been defined.

And thanks for telling me to 'get over it'. I make three people unemployed later this month - directly Brexit related.

I'll pass on your regards.
Boro Boy wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 12:59pm
The price of freedom never comes cheap!
As if you've ever paid a price for "freedom".
Remarks like that merely go to highlight that you know nothing...!

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 2:21pm
by Chadwick
expressman33 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
There is a cost either way and the fact remains that Britain was paying an extremely high amount compared to other countries to stay in the EU.
Except that's not a fact.
Each country's contribution is based on their national income. The UK pays proportionally less than the others because we have a rebate.

If you think it's unfair that we pay more than other countries in actual £, remember it's because we are a rich country. If we were a poor country, we would pay less, but you would be living in a poor country.


If your argument for leaving is that it's unfair that rich members contribute more than poor members, because the amount is based on % of income, then you may also find the UK tax system is not for you.

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 2:30pm
by Chadwick
expressman33 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
Its done now so people need to accept the result and get over it as they should've when it was voted for. We've lost more money with the uncertainty and still didn't get as bad as predicted.
a) It's not done. It's barely started.

b) As for people not accepting the result, presumably you mean people like Boris Johnson, Priti Patel, Dominic Raab, Grant Shapps and Theresa Villiers. They all voted against Theresa May's Withdrawal Agreement. This, as you will recall, prolonged the process and ultimately brought the government down.

c) "It's not as bad as predicted" is not justification for anything.

Re: Brexit will have soon cost the UK more than all its payments to the EU over the past 47 years put together

Posted: Wed Jan 15 2020 4:44pm
by Boro Boy
Chadwick wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 2:30pm
expressman33 wrote:
Wed Jan 15 2020 1:19pm
Its done now so people need to accept the result and get over it as they should've when it was voted for. We've lost more money with the uncertainty and still didn't get as bad as predicted.
a) It's not done. It's barely started.

b) As for people not accepting the result, presumably you mean people like Boris Johnson, Priti Patel, Dominic Raab, Grant Shapps and Theresa Villiers. They all voted against Theresa May's Withdrawal Agreement. This, as you will recall, prolonged the process and ultimately brought the government down.

c) "It's not as bad as predicted" is not justification for anything.
All the scaremongers seem to be moving their goal posts now... :wtf: